Monday, July 9, 2012

Thing 16 - Reference and Research Tools

1. I used the two SIRS databases to compare the available resources for the My Lai Massacre, one of the key events of the Vietnam War. I thought such a controversial subject would provide a more clear contrast between the two dbs in terms of what was deemed appropriate material depending on the age of the student. The SIRS Renaissance database had many more resources than the Discoverer Deluxe. Many of those resources were tangential to the main subject.  For example, there were numerous articles related to protest music and even underground comic books and album cover designs.  Perhaps these search results are too broad.  Neither db provided any of the photographic evidence of the massacre, which was really one of the most important components of the story.  The SIRS DD database narrowed the most useful results down to one NY Times article from 2006, and then it did provide some good lesson plan ideas at the end of the article.  I did not see that any of the Renaissance articles provided the same.  The credibility of the databases seemed good for both, but they also both seemed limited in the information presented.

2. For me the SIRS Renaissance database has the most useful data.  The tangential articles on music, the Vietnam War in film, war protests, from a simple search on My Lai opens up broad new possibilities. The materials are appropriate for providing sources for projects, which I'm always on the lookout for. Most of the articles are from reputable magazines and newspaper, increasing the likelihood that the information is credible.

3. Mel database citation creator for an article on the classic Cold War film, Dr. Strangelove:

4. Web page citation using BibMe:
 

No comments:

Post a Comment